Article

Undereating Isn't the Flex You Think It Is

By Morgan Peach, MS, RDN, CBSAug 13, 20263 min read

Myth: Eating less is always the answer.

Many people think undereating is the key to success. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out, isn't it? In some ways yes, but that is an over-simplified way of looking at it.

Diet culture has made 1200-1800 Calorie diets feel like the prescription for all weight loss. With GLP-1s flooding the pharmaceutical market, achieving your dream body appears to be easier than ever. This is in part due to the side effects of appetite suppression and GI symptoms. People don't have to think about intentional restriction anymore due to their overall disinterest in food. However, living in an extreme Calorie deficit is not only unrealistic for the long-term, but it can also be dangerous.

The trap: One of the biggest dangers with implementing an intentional Calorie deficit is the temptation to steadily decrease total Calories consumed in a day to accelerate the rate of weight loss.

What undereating actually costs you

The heart and brain alone need an average of 500-650 Calories daily to operate. When people don't eat enough throughout the day, their bodies do not receive what they need to function at baseline. The resulting side effects can be life-altering.

Undereating can cause:

  • Nutrient deficiencies
  • Chronic fatigue
  • Muscle wasting
  • GI symptoms
  • Hormonal disruptions that can lead to infertility
  • Mental health deterioration
  • Bone fractures
  • Increased risk of developing osteoporosis

If a Calorie deficit isn't the answer, what is?

Start with what you can add into your diet rather than take away. Eat 3 meals and 2-3 snacks daily. Increase your fiber intake by making your plate colorful with a delicious variety of fruits and vegetables. (Yes, you can and should eat fruit!) Incorporate protein through lean meats, fish, eggs, tofu, dairy, nuts, and beans.

Keep your favorite water bottle full and near you throughout the day to serve as a motivator to reach your daily water goals. Swap out sodas and sugar-sweetened beverages for flavored water, sugar-free sodas, or prebiotic sodas. Increase physical activity and adequately fuel your body around exercise. Finally, don't underestimate the importance of good sleep for recovery and weight management.

Tip: Macros.gg lets you track your macros and your water intake — for free.

Ready to start adding instead of subtracting?

Still not seeing progress?

If you have added all the above and are still not reaching your goals, consider reaching out to a dietitian or medical provider to determine next steps. A small Calorie deficit of 300-500 Calories less than what you were receiving before may be helpful. However, prescribing yourself a set amount of Calories without consulting a professional first can lead to undereating and may lead to rebound weight gain when the diet fails.

Disclaimer: If you are currently active in an eating disorder, have history of an eating disorder, or are experiencing severe body dysmorphia, Macros.gg recommends you do not attempt a Calorie deficit and seek medical guidance immediately.

About the author

Morgan Peach

Morgan Peach — MS, RDN, CBS

Morgan is a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist and practicing clinical dietitian who helps shape Macros.gg's features and guidance on an ongoing basis.

Follow Morgan on Instagram